Skip to main content

Incredibles 2 All-New Teaser Trailer, Poster & Image

Movie Review: 'Brooklyn'

The period piece moves with a gentle grace, but it's story can't keep up.

Review by Matt Cummings

In Director John Crowley's period drama Brooklyn, the meager Irish woman Eilis (Saoirse Ronan) comes to America during the 1950's in search of a better life. Leaving behind the only world she's ever known, Eilis initially struggles in New York, working at a well-respected department store but feeling completely empty and homesick. Although she's set up in a boarding home with other Irish female immigrants, Eilis struggles to adjust to her new life, until she meets the Italian plumber Tony (Emory Cohen), who is immediately smitten with her. But when tragedy forces her to return home, Eilis is immediately courted by Jim (Domhnall Gleeson) and must make a difficult decision: stay and enjoy an opulent life or take a chance on Brooklyn and the love which awaits her.

Based on the novel by Colm Toibin, Brooklyn is beautifully shot and well acted, with Ronan turning in a delicate performance. One feels a pull to the era, as Crowley has transported us to watch this story unfold without their knowledge. But it's all superficial as Writer Nick Hornby doesn't give Ronan enough to do, and never creates a sense controversy, keeping his chaarcters fairly one-note throughout the production. Nearly everyone outside of Eilis and Tom are just amalgams, impediments that she must dodge or scurry past on her way to whatever seemingly dull life she's set up for herself. Moreover, there's never the sense that Eilis has anything truly to suffer for, that her life will be good if she just sticks to her interests and pushes on through. There's some suggestion that the Irish had some difficulties in America, but we've seen these kinds of struggles play out better in the elegant Avalon.

Ronan has proved her worth in Hanna, but here she's so reserved that Eilis never gets a chance to tell her story about the immigrant experience in America. Gleeson's no more than a glorified cameo, content to not even show up until the third act. He and Ronan have decent chemistry, but it's Cohen who shines the brightest, providing the best Italian accent I've heard in years, his love for the Brooklyn Dodgers/hatred for the Yankees as real as I can remember from my Italian upbringing. I think real stars here are Julie Walters as the boarding house marm, whose strict Catholic values clash hilariously with the ruckus girls that include Arrow's Emily Bett Rickards, as well as Father Flood played by Jim Broadbent. Both stand as bright lights against the rather effects produced by the leads.

But without any real conflict to keep the story moving, Brooklyn begins to sway of course, settling into a passive avenue of storytelling where everyone largely behaves themselves, does what they're told, and treats Eilis with enough love to float the cruise ship that brings her to America. Had it been made 40 years ago, Brooklyn might have found itself in privileged company, the center of TCM spotlights and repeated airings. Unfortunately, such gentleness doesn't feel as relevant as it once did, perhaps saying more about where our culture is headed than a criticism of the movie. Regardless, it never uses its pieces very well, and the lack of direction wastes the immense talent compiled to service it.

Brooklyn is rated Rated PG-13 for a scene of sexuality and brief strong language and has a runtime of 111 minutes.

Discuss this review with fellow SJF fans on Facebook. On Twitter, follow us at @SandwichJohnFilms, and follow author Matt Cummings at @mfc90125.


Popular posts from this blog

Morbius: The Living Vampire Film In The Works

The Spider spin-offs keep on coming! With Venom now shooting, an even more obscure character from the web-slinger's extensive comicbook past has now been unearthed, with plans for a movie. Power Rangers writing duo Matt Sazama and Burk Sharpless are in talks to craft the script for Morbius: The Living Vampire.

Sony is pushing ahead with another potential Spider-movie, which, like Venom, is unlikely to be linked to the MCU. What it will boast, however, is the story of Michael Morbius, a Nobel Prize-winning biochemist who tries to cure a rare blood disease using an experimental treatment that combines electroshock therapy and vampire bats. The results are predictably catastrophic, and he's transformed into... well, the title should be a clue. He has some of the traditional vampiric qualities – he ingests blood to live, and conversely is not fond of bright light. He can fly, has superhuman strength and healing capabilities. When he bites victims and drinks their blood, his attac…

Enter For A Chance To Win A Family Four Pack To See COCO In Minnesota

© 2017 Disney/Pixar Enter for your chance to win a family four pack to see COCO in Minnesota on November 15th at 7:30PM.

In Disney•Pixar’s “Coco,” aspiring musician Miguel (voice of newcomer Anthony Gonzalez) teams up with charming trickster Hector (voice of Gael García Bernal) on an extraordinary journey through the Land of the Dead.

In theatres November 22!


Facebook: /PixarCoco
Twitter: @pixarcoco
Hashtag: #PixarCoco

While supplies last. Once all allotted passes are redeemed, the code will no longer be valid. Supplies are limited.

NO PURCHASE NECESSARY. Limit one (1) admit-two pass per person. This film is rated PG. Must be 13 years of age or older to win passes. Employees of all promotional partners and their agencies are not eligible. Void where prohibited. Entries must be received by [12:00PM], [11-19-2017] to be eligible to receive pass. Winners will be contacted via e-mail to receive their pass. Sponsors not responsible for…

Enter For A Chance To Win Passes To See DARKEST HOUR In Dallas

Enter For A Chance To Win Passes To See DARKEST HOUR on December 5th at 7:00 PM in Dallas

During the early days of World War II, with the fall of France imminent, Britain faces its darkest hour as the threat of invasion looms. As the seemingly unstoppable Nazi forces advance, and with the Allied army cornered on the beaches of Dunkirk, the fate of Western Europe hangs on the leadership of the newly-appointed British Prime Minister Winston Churchill (Academy Award nominee Gary Oldman). While maneuvering around his political rivals, he must confront the ultimate choice: negotiate with Hitler and save the British people at a terrible cost or rally the nation and fight on against incredible odds. Directed by Joe Wright, DARKEST HOUR is the dramatic and inspiring story of four weeks in 1940 during which Churchill’s courage to lead changed the course of world history.