Skip to main content


TV Review: The X-Files "Home Again"

Two great episodes are trash-compacted into a single uneven one.

Review by Brandon Wolfe

“Home Again,” written by another X-Files MVP, Glen Morgan (who also co-wrote possibly the best episode of the entire series with the similarly titled, yet unrelated “Home”), is an episode with a severe identity crisis. Perhaps as a byproduct of the unusually low number of episodes in this limited engagement, it’s essentially two wholly distinct episodes battling it out for dominance in an hourlong arena. Two very good episodes, it must be said, but two highly incompatible ones. Had “Home Again” chosen a side for which story it wanted to tell, it might have been a new classic. As it stands, it’s a deeply confused episode of television, its virtues diminished by its bifurcated structure.

In Philadelphia, a HUD official is enacting a relocation plan for the downtown homeless to clear the way for good ol’ gentrification to commence, a plan that includes fire hoses and excises compassion. Returning to his office that night, he is visited by a tall, ghastly man, who tears the official in two with the ease that a regular person might tear up a piece of junk mail. The mysterious man vacates the premises holding the official’s severed arms before disappearing into the compactor in the back of the garbage truck in which he arrived. Unsurprisingly, Mulder and Scully are called to the scene to investigate, where they encounter some light jurisdictional resistance from local law enforcement.

It’s here where “Home Again” skews into a tangent, as Scully receives a call from her brother that their mother has been hospitalized from a heart attack. Scully immediately takes her leave of the crime scene while Mulder sticks around, quickly noticing an ominous piece of artwork depicting a hanging man that is visible from the office’s window, yet did not appear on the security-camera footage from the night before. As Mulder attempts to locate the artist, Scully sits at her unconscious mother’s bedside, learning that her final words to the attending staff were to ask about her estranged son Charlie, a revelation that puzzles Scully. Scully also learns that her mother recently changed her living will to state that she no longer wishes to be kept alive on life support, meaning that the hospital only has a certain amount of time before they are legally required to extubate the patient. Scully is hoping for a miracle so that she can ask her mother a few final questions before they are separated forever.

The monster-of-the-week portion of “Home Again” is fairly exemplary. The killer, we find out, is a sculpture—identified by a Band-Aid on its nose—that the artist inadvertently brought to life as a “thought form” fueled by his anger toward the city’s treatment of the homeless. The creature comes to life on its own and wreaks bloody vengeance against those seeking to displace the less fortunate for personal gain, and the scenes where it stalks and attacks are extremely creepy (maggots are prominent). The problem is that the Band-Aid Nose Man has the misfortune of having his episode hijacked by the Scully material. And it’s not a matter of the Scully material not being strong. It’s very emotionally effective, but these two storylines have no business occupying the same space. There isn’t even a real thematic link between the two. It’s as though the show had the strong desire to provide the characters with this affecting dramatic material, but realized that such material does not lend itself to an episode of The X-Files (especially considering how few this run has to spare), so it was inorganically grafted onto what was intended to be a pure stand-alone horror entry.

Needless to say, the graft doesn’t take. The Band-Aid Man half and the Scully half are both quite adroit at what each is trying to do, but they’re working at cross purposes, and watching the episode lurch back and forth between the two is jarring. Scully’s mother ultimately passes away after a fleeting moment of cognizance and Scully opts to deal with her grief by channeling herself back into the case, ordering Mulder to drive her back to Philadelphia immediately to resume the case. It’s not that this action is necessarily out of character for Scully, but leaping from devastating heartache directly back into flashlight-in-the-dark monster hunting makes the episode feel unwieldy. There exists no chocolate/peanut butter harmoniousness between the two halves of “Home Again.”

The other element that hampers the episode, one that threatens this entire mini-season, is the continued focus on William, Mulder and Scully’s lost son. Scully’s mother’s last words are in reference to the child, reigniting Scully’s feelings of abandonment due to giving the boy up for adoption all those years ago, and the closest thing to a unifying thread between the disparate components of the episode is Scully imparting to Mulder that she hopes William doesn’t think they threw him away “like trash.” One takes away from “Home Again” that the Scully material really only exists to keep William at the forefront of our minds for whatever Carter plans to do to us in his final two episodes. The kid has now been significantly mentioned in three of the four episodes aired thus far, giving the clear indication that he’s soon to play a major role in the ongoing storyline. The X-Files’ stubborn insistence on holding onto a misbegotten story thread best left forgotten is infuriating. Some things most certainly do belong in the trash.

Discuss this review with fellow SJF fans on Facebook. On Twitter, follow us at @SandwichJohnFilms, and follow author Brandon Wolfe at @BrandonTheWolfe.


Popular posts from this blog

NEW Clip From SABOTAGE And Images From Surprise Screening

Things get heated between Arnold and his team in this tense new clip from SABOTAGE. This brand new clip shows how pressure begins to rise between this elite DEA squad, as everything starts unraveling after a big drug bust. From the writer of Training Day and the director of End of Watch, this thriller will have you guessing until the end. Get to the bottom of this mystery on MARCH 28th- but until then, be sure to watch the new clip below.

This past weekend Arnold Schwarzenegger gave fans a BIG surprise at the annual ARNOLD SPORTS FESTIVAL, where he and Joe Manganiello met with fans at a special screening of SABOTAGE! Just after that, the dynamic duo headed over to Chicago for another surprise appearance.

SABOTAGE hits theaters everywhere MARCH 28th, 2014!

In "SABOTAGE", Arnold Schwarzenegger leads an elite DEA task force that takes on the world's deadliest drug cartels. When the team successfully executes a high-stakes raid on a cartel safe house, they think their work i…

Enter For A Chance To Win Passes To See DEN OF THIEVES In OHIO

Enter For A Chance To Win Passes To See DEN OF THIEVES on January 16th at 7:00 PM in OHIO.

Every day, $120mm in cash is taken out of circulation and destroyed by the Los Angeles Branch of the Federal Reserve - unless a notorious, elite crew of bank robbers can pull off the ultimate heist and get to the money first... right under the noses of LA's most feared division in law enforcement.

The film stars Gerard Butler, Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson, O’Shea Jackson Jr and Pablo Schreiber.


In Theaters January 19, 2018





This screening will be monitored for unauthorized recording. By attending, you agree not to bring any audio and/or visual recording device including laptop computers into th…

Enter For A Chance To Win Tickets To See 12 STRONG In Las Vegas

Enter For A Chance To Win Passes To See 12 STRONG on January 16th at 7:00 PM in Las Vegas.

Chris Hemsworth and Oscar nominee, Michael Shannon, star in 12 STRONG.

Set in the harrowing days following 9/11, a U.S. Special Forces team, led by their new Captain, Mitch Nelson (Chris Hemsworth), is chosen to be the first U.S. troops sent into Afghanistan for an extremely dangerous mission. There, in the rugged mountains, they must convince Northern Alliance General Dostum (Navid Negahban) to join forces with them to fight their common adversary: the Taliban and their Al Qaeda allies. In addition to overcoming mutual distrust and a vast cultural divide, the Americans—accustomed to state-of-the-art warfare—must adopt the rudimentary tactics of the Afghani horse soldiers. But despite their uneasy bond, the new allies face overwhelming odds: outnumbered and outgunned by a ruthless enemy that does not take prisoners.

Directed by Nicolai Fuglsig and based on the acclaimed “Horse Soldiers” book by …